As long as I have been alive sports teams have had captains. As coaches, we have been conditioned to accept that this is how it should be. I'm going to ask you to really think about whether your team should have captains. I'm not going to tell you that you shouldn't, but I am going to tell you that if you have captains, but do not have leadership, you are setting yourself up for team turmoil.
Being a captain of a team is not a job that should be taken lightly. It comes with great responsibility that most youths are not experienced in or even capable of. It takes a very special young athlete to be able to handle the responsibility and pressure that comes with the job. Jeff Janssen is one of the most knowledgeable gurus in sports leadership and he has an entire program dedicated to mentoring team captains. His book is almost 200 pages on the topic. It is important to understand that you can't elect captains without educating and training them on what being a captain is.
Many athletes believe that being a captains means that it is your job to yell at your team when things are not going well or when the team is not playing well. This is NOT what a captain is. A captain needs to be a player that mediates team conflicts, acts as a liaison between the players and coaches, gives teammates positive reinforcement and motivation and takes personal responsibility for the team. This takes a very mature and confident young man or woman to accomplish.
There are a few situations where you should absolutely look closely to see if captains are the best idea for your team leadership. Please accept that these statements are very general and there may be exceptions.
- Any team that is not at the varsity level. Young kids do not have the skills needed to be an effective captain, nor do they have the skills needed to accept the leadership of their peers. They have not developed the communication and inter-personal skills needed.
- Girl's teams. Girls are much more social than boys. Girls are also much more concerned with making their teammates upset and they often worry about their friends being mad at them. Likewise, they are more likely to take any criticism from a peer as a personal attack.
- You don't have two or three players that are obvious leaders. If it takes you more than two seconds to know who your captains are, then you probably don't have any.
Remember, these are general comments. There are many girls and younger players that will be great captains. These are scenarios where you should be absolutely sure that you have the right athletes before naming captains.
If you decide that you do not want captains, you still need leadership on your team. How do you get it?
- Everyone is a captain. Teach your team that you expect everyone to act like a captain. Explain the expectations for them. Your true leaders will be very obvious in a short period of time to you and the team. The players will have individuals that they look to and you will get leadership without the stress of the title of captain.
- Weekly captains. Change who the captains are week to week. Base your decision on practices and games from the previous week and explain to the team on Monday why the players were selected. Each week you will announce the captains. Some weeks the names will change and some weeks they will not.
- Delegate certain jobs to different players that you want to take on leadership roles. One player might be in charge of your dynamic stretching, another could get their position started during their individual time, and another could be in charge of putting a schedule together for who gets water on game day.
You can have a leader without a captain, but you can not have a captain without a leader. Develop the leader and then and only then should you have a captain.
Find us on Facebook and Twitter!